Chicken Wings
Prime Rib
Shrimp Cocktail
Swiss Mushroom Chicken Sandwich
Killbuck Pie
Deluxe Burger
Brownie Sundae
4 Piece Sicilian Garlic Sauce Pizza
Tucked along NY-36 in Canisteo, the Killbuck Inn Menu brings together that small-town warmth with hearty, satisfying flavors that keep people coming back. It’s the kind of place where comfort food meets easy conversation - think juicy burgers stacked tall, crispy wings tossed in your favorite sauce, and perfectly grilled steaks that hit the spot after a long day. You’ll also find homestyle specials that change with the seasons, each one made to taste just right without overcomplicating things. Whether you’re grabbing lunch with friends or winding down with a pint at dinner, there’s always something inviting on the plate. The laid-back setting matches the food’s honest simplicity, making it a go-to stop for anyone passing through 4900 NY-36 or locals looking for that familiar, satisfying bite.